Photo: Laura James

Should I nail or screw shelves?

artofmanliness.com - DIY Woodworking: Should You Use Nails or Screws? | Art of Manliness

How close can shed be to boundary?

With all of this in mind, we recommend leaving ideally a 2 metre gap between your shed and the fence of any neighbouring properties. Doing so...

Last updated Jan 16, 2018

What does ACX plywood stand for?

ACX plywood has grade “A” face and grade “C” back the “X” standards for exposure. These sheets can handle moisture as its bonded with waterproof...

Last updated Mar 16, 2020

Can I build my own shed?

Yes, with the right plans you can build your dream shed.

Learn More »

Promotion

You’ve got a weekend project that involves working with wood. Maybe you’re building a weightlifting platform or a workbench or a dining room table.

Whatever your DIY project, one question is likely to arise: should you use nails or screws to fasten the pieces of wood together?

Below we lay out the considerations that answer a query that has riddled many a man’s mind while walking the aisles of Home Depot.

Understanding Grip Strength and Shear Strength

To know when to use nails or screws, you first need to understand the difference between grip strength and shear strength. Grip strength is the ability of a fastener to draw wood together. You typically want a lot of grip strength when force is placed vertically on a fastener and the pieces of wood it’s securing together. The best example of this is decking. When you walk on a deck, you’re applying vertical force on the decking planks and joists. You want them drawn tightly together so they don’t come apart. Shear strength is the amount of force a fastener can handle from the sides. Using our deck example, a fastener used to connect the joist to the deck frame would experience shear force, so you’d want to use one with a lot of shear strength.

Screws for Grip Strength; Nails for Shear Strength

Screws are actually pretty brittle compared to nails. If you apply enough shear force to the side of a screw, it snaps. You may have seen a screw head pop off while driving one into wood before. So screws don’t have a lot of shear strength. While screws don’t have a lot of shear strength, they do provide a lot of grip and tensile strength. Screws will keep wood together when faced with vertical force and won’t break down when lots of vertical force is applied to them. Nails are able to bend under pressure, and rarely snap when subjected to shear force. They’ve got a lot of shear strength. But they don’t have a lot of grip or tensile strength. So with that in mind, when you’ve got a project where weight or gravity bears down on the fastener, a screw is your best option. This scenario will be the most common in your DIY projects; the weightlifting platform, workbench, and table mentioned above are all examples of times you use screws to fasten the wood together. If the fastener will bear more side-to-side movement, a nail is the better choice. And of course, sometimes you use both; when building a sawhorse, you’d use screws for the I-beam section, and then nails to attach legs to it.

Don’t Forget Context

While screws are better fasteners when grip strength is needed and nails the best fastener for when shear strength is needed, either one will work in most situations. Even seasoned builders will use screws when a nail would have been better simply because it’s easier to remove a screw in case of a mess-up. You just flip your power drill into reverse. Getting a nail out is harder. Sometimes they’ll use a nail even when a screw would be the best option because of aesthetic reasons. Nails, particularly small nails, don’t leave much of an imprint in wood after you’ve nailed them in. You have to consider your context, use your phronesis or practical wisdom, and pick the best option. With experience, you’ll learn when it’s best to use nails or screws or when it doesn’t matter so much.

How do you stabilize a floating dock?

When a dock needs to be set away from the shore to reach a specific desired water depth, gangways and ramps are the ideal solutions for...

Last updated Dec 22, 2021

Does a detached office add value to home?

Does a Detached Office Add Value to a Home? A detached office could be a selling point for some buyers, but that depends on what other spaces the...

Last updated Feb 12, 2022

Promotion

Do Keter sheds need concrete base?

It's recommended that you construct a timber or concrete base for the Keter 2160 x 2180 x 2260mm Artisan Shed.

workshop.bunnings.com.au - Pavers for Keter Artisan shed base | Bunnings Workshop community

This is the 7x9 version, but the base shows what I hope can be done with pavers.

The back of our house and area for eventual paving.

I am planning to buy a Keter Artisan shed and wanted some suggestions please on pavers for a shed foundation. Would bluestone pavers work? What would I need to consider in sizing and pricing pavers for a shed base? I’m thinking of the Artisan 7x7 shed and would like to extend the pavers beyond the shed on one side to create space for a garden bench. I would like to later use the same paver colour and type for landscaped pavers in sand around the back of our house and for a patio in front of the glass doors. I thought the shed base could be a good introductory project for my husband and I, as we haven’t done any kind of paving before. Very grateful for guidance! I’ve attached a photo of the back of our house in case that is useful.

Should I wrap paper bubble wrap or glass?

Bubble wrap is fantastic for protection. But if left in direct contact with glass items it can potentially leave circular pattern marks that are...

Last updated Jul 18, 2021

Does metal roofing require an underlayment?

The short answer is yes, your metal roof does need underlayment . But like most things in life, it's not quite that simple. At Western States Metal...

Last updated Mar 19, 2022

Promotion

How long after cutting down a tree can you split the wood?

A stack of whole logs can take a year or longer to fully season, whereas a similar-sized stack of split wood may take just six months to season....

Last updated Jun 10, 2019

Promotion

How long does it take to become a master craftsman?

The duration of the courses takes 1 to 4 years depending on the craft and on the Course. The examination includes theoretical, practical and oral...

Last updated Dec 7, 2022