Should you put Styrofoam under concrete?

Rigid foam insulations, such as expanded polystyrene (EPS), have been used successfully under concrete slabs for more than 40 years. Such insulation helps reduce heat loss to the ground in residences, cold storage units, warehouses and other commercial, institutional and industrial structures.

structuremag.org - Right-sizing Under-slab Insulation - STRUCTURE magazine |

Is Jesus a carpenter?

In those verses, Jesus and Joseph are called tektōn, which is most frequently rendered “carpenter” by Bible translators. In an excerpt published at...

Last updated Jan 16, 2018

Why does my shed wobble?

Your shed wobbles because of low-quality materials, poor craftsmanship, or damage. It's essential to correct a wobbly shed; otherwise, the shed may...

Last updated Feb 10, 2021

Promotion

Applying the Theory of Plates on Elastic Foundations to Save Material Costs

A common, simplifying assumption used for specifying polystyrene insulation under concrete slabs results in material costs that are significantly higher than necessary. Using a design equation based on a more rigorous analysis of the design conditions can help avoid over-engineering the insulation and save thousands of dollars on the project. Rigid foam insulations, such as expanded polystyrene (EPS), have been used successfully under concrete slabs for more than 40 years. Such insulation helps reduce heat loss to the ground in residences, cold storage units, warehouses and other commercial, institutional and industrial structures. The problem is that designers often do not adequately account for how the concrete slab and underlying subgrade interact. Many designers assume that a concentrated load applied to the slab transfers to the rigid foam subgrade through a triangular load path. This assumption, while not necessarily incorrect, can be very conservative. Concrete slabs distribute loads in a more even fashion, which means that the insulation does not need as high a compressive resistance compared to the typical simplified approach. A more accurate approach to this problem is to use the Modulus of Subgrade Reaction (K) to determine the slab’s deflection and the resultant stress applied to the elastic insulation subgrade. The pressure beneath a given slab under a load can be determined using the following formula, found in the Theory of Plates on Elastic Foundations, as described by Timoshenko and Woinowsky-Krieger:

Pressure on the subgrade = (P/8)√(K/D)

Where:

P = concentrated load on concrete slab in pounds

K = Subgrade reaction modulus of total EPS insulation in pounds per cubic inch (k/t) k = Stiffness of one inch of EPS insulation in pounds per square inch

t = EPS insulation thickness in inches

D = Eh 3 / 12(1-u 2 )

/ 12(1-u ) E = Modulus of elasticity of concrete in pounds per square inch (57000√ f ‘ c ) ) f ‘ c = specified concrete compressive strength in pounds per square inch = specified concrete compressive strength in pounds per square inch h = Thickness of concrete slab in inches

u = Poisson’s ratio for concrete (0.15)

An example illustrates the significant difference in the calculated results.

Take the case of a warehouse with a 6-inch-thick, 2,500-psi concrete slab on 2 inches of EPS insulation with a rated stiffness of 360 psi for one inch. Forklifts to be used in the building impart 8,000 pounds of force at the wheel, which has a 6-inch by 10-inch tire footprint on the slab. If the designer assumes that this load distributes at a 45-degree angle through the slab, the 8,000 pounds ends up distributed over approximately 396 square inches [(6 + 6 + 6)(6 + 10 + 6)] of the insulation’s surface, for an average pressure of 20.2 psi. Taking into account the fact that concrete slabs distribute loads more evenly, using the Modulus of Subgrade Reaction method, the pressure on the insulation is actually much lower – approximately 1.85 psi. Since EPS insulation rated for 1.85 psi costs about 50% less than other rigid foam insulations rated for the much higher value of 20.2 psi, using the more precise method reduces insulation costs substantially. In fact, the 20.2 psi value is beyond the elastic range of the EPS material, and long-term creep effects must be taken into account when using that design approach. With:

How long do modular homes last?

30-100 years Most modular homes will last 30-100 years. However, this depends on the materials used and how well they are maintained. They're built...

Last updated May 7, 2021

How do you keep plants warm in a shed?

Cover Your Plants. You don't have to spend a lot to keep plants warm outside. Old sheets and blankets work perfectly well. Drape them over...

Last updated Aug 23, 2020

Are shed plans easy to follow?

These are! They guide you every step of the way to complete your dream shed.

Learn More »

Promotion

P = 8000 pounds, h = 6 inches, f ‘ c = 2,500 psi, E = 57,000√ 2,500 = 2,850,000 psi, u = 0.15, k = 360 psi for 1-inch EPS

K = 360 psi / 2 inches = 180 pci

D = Eh3/12(1-u2) = 2,850,000 (6)3/12(1–(0.15)2) = 52,480,818 lb-in

Pressure on EPS = (P/8)√(K/D) = 8000/8 √(180 / 52,480,818) = 1.85 psi. The k value can be found by consulting the insulation manufacturer. One EPS insulation brand available throughout the U.S. has k values ranging from 360 to 1860 psi for one inch of insulation thickness. The specific value depends on the product type selected. Note that increasing the thickness of EPS insulation decreases the overall subgrade modulus. Using the above method to determine the pressure that a slab transfers to the subgrade allows for proper specification of rigid foam insulation and avoids over-engineering the insulation for compressive strength. In the example application discussed in this article, the simplifying assumption of triangular load transfer through a concrete slab results in a compressive force on the insulation 11 times higher than the result from the more rigorous (but not much more complicated) analysis. Specifying higher compressive resistance insulation than necessary not only is overly conservative for the given design, it also does not improve the insulation’s thermal performance, and the cost to the project is excessive and unnecessary. It is a lose-lose scenario.▪

structuremag.org - Right-sizing Under-slab Insulation - STRUCTURE magazine |

What is cheaper bricks or cinder blocks?

Which One Cost More? The cost of clay bricks and concrete blocks are pretty comparable – and tend to vary by as little as 20 cents a block, with...

Last updated Apr 19, 2018

Why should you avoid aluminum foil?

Cooking With Aluminum Foil May Increase the Aluminum Content of Foods. Most of your aluminum intake comes from food. However, studies show that...

Last updated Mar 30, 2020

Are shed plans easy to follow?

These are! They guide you every step of the way to complete your dream shed.

Learn More »

Promotion

Does a big shed increase home value?

In terms of money, the exact amount that your shed can add on to your property will vary depending on its size and purpose. However, it's generally...

Last updated Feb 27, 2022

Promotion

How do you anchor a wooden shed to the ground?

How to Properly Anchor a Shed: The Only Guide You Need Drill or dig the holes, tamp some gravel into the bottom. Slide a sonotube in to form it up....

Last updated Jul 25, 2020